Difference between revisions of "Genealogical Classification by Family Group Coding for Descent from Common Ancestors"

From Crews Genealogy Wiki: focusing on the Wiregrass south, and related families
Jump to navigation Jump to search
 
(6 intermediate revisions by the same user not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
 +
Citation date: [[has citation date::22 Mar 2014]]
 +
 
=Bibliographic Information=
 
=Bibliographic Information=
−
:Title: Genealogical Classification by Family Group Coding for Descent from Common Ancestors, Genealogical Classification by Family Group Coding for Descent from Common Ancestors, Cameron Ralph Stewart, Volumes 1 and 2.
+
:Title: [[has title::Genealogical Classification by Family Group Coding for Descent from Common Ancestors, Genealogical Classification by Family Group Coding for Descent from Common Ancestors, Cameron Ralph Stewart, Volumes 1 and 2.]]
−
:AuthorCameron Ralph Stewart
+
:Author: [[has author::Cameron Ralph Stewart]] of Long Beach
−
:PublisherC.R. Stewart, 1986
+
:Publisher: [[has publisher::C.R. Stewart, 1986]]
−
:Original fromthe University of Wisconsin - Madison
+
:Digitized: Jan 17, 2008
−
:DigitizedJan 17, 2008
+
:Length: [[has length::2259 pages]]
−
:Length2259 pages
 
  
 
=Notes=
 
=Notes=
−
==Summary==
+
*This document can be found at [https://archive.org/embed/genealogicalclas02stew]
−
This is a professionally bound and published two volume book containing short histories of progenitors and a list of their descendants. Each descendant is coded alphanumerically to convey their relationship from one their progenitors<ref>A more precise explanation of the system can be located on page 9 in the preface.</ref>, along with gender, marriage, and other information when known.   
+
==The Document==
 +
The publication has a 1986 copyright. Each descendant is coded alphanumerically to convey their relationship from one their progenitors<ref>A more precise explanation of the system can be located on page 9 in the preface.</ref>, along with gender, marriage, and other information when known.   
  
−
The author explains "the information utilized has been in appearance both laid and reliable"<ref name="page 13">{{Citation:Genealogical Classification by Family Group Coding for Descent from Common Ancestors/Volume 1/Citation Listing}}13.</ref> . While he believes this to be true, he also states "the reader should carefuly weigh the evidence on the basis of the indicated sources"<ref name="page 13" />.  In fact, I have already identified a [[#Known Issues|few inaccuracies]].
+
'''Volume 1''' contains the family groups of  Scotcanam Mclean-Stewart (St:), Isle-of-Arram McAlister-McMaster (Me:), Amcanam Sarles (Sa:), Smcanam Sharrard (Sh:), Amcanam Badgerow (Ba:), Norsam Gjerde-Gjere (Gj:,Mi:), Norsam Osmundsdatter-knutson (Os:).  '''Volume 2''' contains Engamcanam Bentl(e)y (Be:), Amcanam Shippee (Sp:).  The '''appendix''' includes descriptions of Westchester County, NY during the revolution<ref>{{Citation:Genealogical Classification by Family Group Coding for Descent from Common Ancestors/Volume 2/Citation Listing}}961.</ref>, and article on the Loyalist Beverly Robinson<ref>{{Citation:Genealogical Classification by Family Group Coding for Descent from Common Ancestors/Volume 2/Subsequent Note}}964.</ref>, Loyalist Claimants<ref>{{Citation:Genealogical Classification by Family Group Coding for Descent from Common Ancestors/Volume 2/Subsequent Note}}990.</ref>, excerpt from ''The history of Toronto and County of York Ontario'' the article ''The war of 1812 through the eyes of a canadian''<ref>{{Citation:Genealogical Classification by Family Group Coding for Descent from Common Ancestors/Volume 2/Subsequent Note}}994.</ref>, Some badg(e)ro(w)s and their associates in ontario county new york during the early 1800's, William Berczy and some early settlers of Markham township of york county, upper Canada<ref>{{Citation:Genealogical Classification by Family Group Coding for Descent from Common Ancestors/Volume 2/Subsequent Note}}1007.</ref>, old township maps for the counties york, ontario, wellington, and hastings in upper Canada (ontario)<ref>{{Citation:Genealogical Classification by Family Group Coding for Descent from Common Ancestors/Volume 2/Subsequent Note}}1025.</ref>
  
−
Most of the facts presented appears to be from personal correspondence between the author and with the individuals listed when living. He asked them to provide genealogical information and primary sources when available. The author seems to imply that not everyone provided the same level of detail and documentation during this process <ref name="page 13" />.
+
==Physical Analysis==
 +
This is a professionally bound and published two volume book consisting of 2259 page containing short histories of  and a list of their descendants. No pages appear to be missing, and all pages examined are clearly legible.
  
−
==Citations in this Source==
+
==Content Analysis==
 +
The author explains "the information utilized has been in appearance both laid and reliable"<ref>{{Citation:Genealogical Classification by Family Group Coding for Descent from Common Ancestors/Volume 1/Citation Listing}}13.</ref> .  While he believes this to be true, he also states "the reader should carefuly weigh the evidence on the basis of the indicated sources"<ref name="page 13" />.  In fact, I have already identified a [[#Known Issues|few inaccuracies]]. 
  
 +
Most of the facts presented appears to be from personal correspondence between the author and with the individuals listed when living.  He asked them to provide genealogical information and primary sources when available.  The author seems to imply that not everyone provided the same level of detail and documentation during this process <ref name="page 13">{{Citation:Genealogical Classification by Family Group Coding for Descent from Common Ancestors/Volume 1/Subsequent Note}}13.</ref>.
  
−
==Known Issues==
+
Some source citations are present throughout the text, include documents, and some individuals who provided content.
−
*Page 1316 states Andrew Birkett and Irene Palmer had 4 children <ref name="page 1316">{{Citation:Creating Genealogical Classification by Family Group Coding for Descent from Common Ancestors/Volume 2/Citation Listing}}1316.</ref>  Irene was Andrew's second wife, and they only had three children, Andrews oldest daughter was with his first wife [[Lizzabelle Electra Bruce Burke]].<ref name="tng cite">{{Citation |url=http://crewsgenealogy.com/tng/getperson.php?personID=I700074231932&tree=Jason-Shannon |title=Crewsgenealogy.com: BIRKETT, Andrew Sherman}}</ref>
 
−
*Page 1316 states Andrew Birkett's youngest son was a missionary to Japan <ref name="page 1316" />.  In fact, it was his eldest daughter, [[Elsie Birket]], who was a missionary to Japan.
 
  
−
Line of interest begins with [[Andrew Birkett]].   
+
===Known Issues===
 +
*Page 1316 states {{has person|Andrew Birkett}} and {{has person|Irene Palmer}} had 4 children <ref>{{Citation:Creating Genealogical Classification by Family Group Coding for Descent from Common Ancestors/Volume 2/Citation Listing}}1316.</ref>  Irene was Andrew's second wife, and they only had three children, Andrews oldest daughter was with his first wife {{has person|Lizzabelle Electra Bruce}}.<ref name="tng cite">{{Citation |url=http://crewsgenealogy.com/tng/getperson.php?personID=I700074231932&tree=Jason-Shannon |title=Crewsgenealogy.com: BIRKETT, Andrew Sherman}}</ref>
 +
*Page 1316 states Andrew Birkett's youngest son was a missionary to Japan <ref name="page 1316">{{Citation:Creating Genealogical Classification by Family Group Coding for Descent from Common Ancestors/Volume 2/Subsequent Note}}1316.</ref>.  In fact, it was his eldest daughter, {{has person|Elsie Rose Birkett}}, who was a missionary to Japan.
  
−
===People in this Source===
+
Line of interest begins with [[Andrew Birkett]].
−
*[[Andrew Birkett]]
 
  
 
=Citation=
 
=Citation=

Latest revision as of 00:23, 25 June 2021

Citation date: 22 Mar 2014

Bibliographic Information

Title: Genealogical Classification by Family Group Coding for Descent from Common Ancestors, Genealogical Classification by Family Group Coding for Descent from Common Ancestors, Cameron Ralph Stewart, Volumes 1 and 2.
Author: Cameron Ralph Stewart of Long Beach
Publisher: C.R. Stewart, 1986
Digitized: Jan 17, 2008
Length: 2259 pages

Notes

  • This document can be found at [1]

The Document

The publication has a 1986 copyright. Each descendant is coded alphanumerically to convey their relationship from one their progenitors[1], along with gender, marriage, and other information when known.

Volume 1 contains the family groups of Scotcanam Mclean-Stewart (St:), Isle-of-Arram McAlister-McMaster (Me:), Amcanam Sarles (Sa:), Smcanam Sharrard (Sh:), Amcanam Badgerow (Ba:), Norsam Gjerde-Gjere (Gj:,Mi:), Norsam Osmundsdatter-knutson (Os:). Volume 2 contains Engamcanam Bentl(e)y (Be:), Amcanam Shippee (Sp:). The appendix includes descriptions of Westchester County, NY during the revolution[2], and article on the Loyalist Beverly Robinson[3], Loyalist Claimants[4], excerpt from The history of Toronto and County of York Ontario the article The war of 1812 through the eyes of a canadian[5], Some badg(e)ro(w)s and their associates in ontario county new york during the early 1800's, William Berczy and some early settlers of Markham township of york county, upper Canada[6], old township maps for the counties york, ontario, wellington, and hastings in upper Canada (ontario)[7]

Physical Analysis

This is a professionally bound and published two volume book consisting of 2259 page containing short histories of and a list of their descendants. No pages appear to be missing, and all pages examined are clearly legible.

Content Analysis

The author explains "the information utilized has been in appearance both laid and reliable"[8] . While he believes this to be true, he also states "the reader should carefuly weigh the evidence on the basis of the indicated sources"[9]. In fact, I have already identified a few inaccuracies.

Most of the facts presented appears to be from personal correspondence between the author and with the individuals listed when living. He asked them to provide genealogical information and primary sources when available. The author seems to imply that not everyone provided the same level of detail and documentation during this process [9].

Some source citations are present throughout the text, include documents, and some individuals who provided content.

Known Issues

Line of interest begins with Andrew Birkett.

Citation

Source Listing

Stewart, Camron Ralph. Genealogical Classification by Family Group Coding for Descent from Common Ancestors. 2 Volumes. Long Beach, California: Camron Ralph Stewart, 1986.

Citation Listing

Volume 1

Camron Ralph Stewart, Genealogical Classification by Family Group Coding for Descent from Common Ancestors. 2 vols. (Long Beach, California: Camron Ralph Stewart, 1986), 1:

Volume 2

Camron Ralph Stewart, Genealogical Classification by Family Group Coding for Descent from Common Ancestors. 2 vols. (Long Beach, California: Camron Ralph Stewart, 1986), 2:

Subsequent Note

Volume 1

Stewart, Genealogical Classificaiton, 1:

Volume 2

Stewart, Genealogical Classificaiton, 2:

Link to Citation

Volume 1

Voume 2

Wiki Codes

Source Listing:
{{Citation:Genealogical Classification by Family Group Coding for Descent from Common Ancestors/Source Listing}}

Volume 1

Citation Listing:
{{Citation:Genealogical Classification by Family Group Coding for Descent from Common Ancestors/Volume 1/Citation Listing}}##.
Subsequent Note:
{{Citation:Genealogical Classification by Family Group Coding for Descent from Common Ancestors/Volume 1/Subsequent Note}}##.

Volume 2


Citation Listing:
{{Citation:Genealogical Classification by Family Group Coding for Descent from Common Ancestors/Volume 2/Citation Listing}}##.
Subsequent Note:
{{Citation:Genealogical Classification by Family Group Coding for Descent from Common Ancestors/Volume 2/Subsequent Note}}##.

Documents From this Source

  • Page 1331

  • Page 1332

  • Page 1333

  • Page 1359

  • Page 1360

  • Page 1361

Notes


References

  1. ↑ A more precise explanation of the system can be located on page 9 in the preface.
  2. ↑ Camron Ralph Stewart, Genealogical Classification by Family Group Coding for Descent from Common Ancestors. 2 vols. (Long Beach, California: Camron Ralph Stewart, 1986), 2:961.
  3. ↑ Stewart, Genealogical Classificaiton, 2:964.
  4. ↑ Stewart, Genealogical Classificaiton, 2:990.
  5. ↑ Stewart, Genealogical Classificaiton, 2:994.
  6. ↑ Stewart, Genealogical Classificaiton, 2:1007.
  7. ↑ Stewart, Genealogical Classificaiton, 2:1025.
  8. ↑ Camron Ralph Stewart, Genealogical Classification by Family Group Coding for Descent from Common Ancestors. 2 vols. (Long Beach, California: Camron Ralph Stewart, 1986), 1:13.
  9. ↑ 9.0 9.1 Stewart, Genealogical Classificaiton, 1:13.
  10. ↑ Camron Ralph Stewart, Genealogical Classification by Family Group Coding for Descent from Common Ancestors. Volume 2 (Long Beach, California: Camron Ralph Stewart, 1986), 2: 1316.
  11. ↑ Template:Citation
  12. ↑ Stewart, Genealogical Classification, 2:1316.
Retrieved from "https://www.crewsgenealogy.com/index.php?title=Genealogical_Classification_by_Family_Group_Coding_for_Descent_from_Common_Ancestors&oldid=25303"