* 1848 - 1856: William Hosmer<ref>https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/William_Hosmer</ref>
+
* 1841 - 1842: John E. Robie<ref>{{Citation:History of the East Genesee Annual Conference - of the Methodist Episcopal Church.pdf/Citation Listing}}, Page 33</ref>
+
* 1842 - 1844: Freeborn C. Hibbard<ref>{{Citation:History of the East Genesee Annual Conference - of the Methodist Episcopal Church.pdf/Citation Listing}}, Page 33</ref>
+
* 1844 - 1856: William Hosmer<ref>https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/William_Hosmer</ref>